Are men or women more sympathetic when the other is sick?

On the radio this morning they had a very interesting discussion question, “which gender is more sympathetic when the other one is sick?” This question found me at a great time because my boyfriend is just starting to get sick and the discussion about how differently men act when they are sick as opposed to women came up.

Now the radio said the survey proved that men are more sympathetic when the other is sick. At first I really did not agree with this. My reasoning was simple. Women tend to be the caretakers. So women tend to be the ones who make their partner soup, make sure they are taking medicine, make sure they are getting rest. While men have good intentions I have no experienced many men who are inclined this way. While my current boyfriend definitely takes care of me, it is not a gender thing but rather a fact that he is a good guy.

He gets a gold star for being awesome!

The more I listened though the more I agreed.

Here is where my first thoughts were wrong. Women are in fact the caretakers but that was never the question. The question was about sympathy. If you take a pole of ten women in the room it is almost guaranteed most women will say men are babies when they are sick (including me). That does not scream sympathy. If anything that is the opposite.

But men don’t generally feel this way about women. Of course the reason could be that many women (including myself) continue on with their daily lives even while sick. Many of us don’t slow down. We are women hear us roar! So men may have more sympathy because they understand how they feel when sick and women don’t show it as much.

Of course these are generalizations and many women and men might fall in the other side of things here which is why I find is such a fascinating discussion questions.

So I turn to you bloggers. Which gender do you feel is more sympathetic when the other is sick and why?

13 thoughts on “Are men or women more sympathetic when the other is sick?

  1. Men, hands down.

    In the past, whenever my girlfriends were sick, I would drop everything I was doing, run to the store, and pick up ginger ale or Sprite; orange juice; hot tea; ice cream; cough lozenges; medicine; etc. I would hand deliver those items and then get my butt in the kitchen to make a pot of chicken noodle soup. I have also been known to give them sympathy get-well cards with sweet handwritten messages inside. I never got the same in return. Granted, I very rarely get sick to begin with, but still.

  2. I freely admit that I’m not a sympathetic person and it cracks me up that neither is my oldest daughter and she’s an RN! I don’t really know if it’s a gender thing or just the particular person. I told my kids to ‘suck it up’ and made them go to school unless they were throwing up! I was a mean mom.

  3. Oh, I have to say that women take first prize on this one. My mother always took great care of me and now my sister and auntie are always checking up on me or strenuously making suggestions about how I should take care of myself.

    Hope your boyfriend feels better, Shae!

  4. Well, I can only speak for myself. I’m very sympathetic when someone is sick (be it a partner, family member, or friend). I don’t like to see anyone in pain or ill, so my heart goes out to them. I also think I was born a natural-caretaker.

    You’re right, though, many women seem to be much tougher when it comes to allowing an illness to slow them down. I’ve always said that I think women are stronger than most men – both emotionally AND physically.

    Once again, my friend, FAB post topic!
    X

  5. I think women are more sympathetic. And we push through. My man is there to carry us through different situations and he’s great at that role. We carry each other through differently so there is balance!

  6. What about those men who try to demonstrate how wonderful they are by showing concern for other women but not to their supposed girlfriend?. Now mind you, they don’t necessarily walk the walk, but I imagine they would like you to notice how wonderful they are by verbalizing concern for “the poor thing “. In this particular instance, this person I have been involved with is trying to be a savior for a manipulative drama queen who landed herself in the hospital by eating an overdose of benedryl. She has now established herself as a special needs person to him and has gotten his attention. Even though when he was in the hospital for a very serious condition, it took her an entire year after his event to contact him, as she is a very self absorbed person. I avoid his place when she threatens to show up, (she, btw, is his wicked stepdaughter ) as I am not going to add to her audience while she relives her drama of how she could have died. No, I see her hospitalization as a giant temper tantrum, and I am not on board as one of her new sympathizers. She has deemed her mother as “toxic ” and unfriended her entire family on fb, (that will show them) except for her step daddy (my soon to be ex) the man who she didn’t contact for an entire year, after he nearly died. I think this B is an audience hopper, and she found a live sucker with her newly sober, but still emotionally recovering stepdad. It gives him a chance to feel like he is a caring person, even though he rarely sees his birth daughter. I never get asked how I am by him. I feel very taken for granted by him, which bothers me, because I DID walk the walk and helped him gain weight and get walking and just engaged in life after his long hospital episode. I am not a cold person, but I have zero sympathy for this manipulative, attention seeking spoiled brat, who has let her ex have custody of her 2 kids. I think she is toxic. Thank you for letting me express myself.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s