Babel: Disconnectedness and Kids with Guns

This past week I saw a movie that was new to me, “Babel” starring Brad Pitt. I didn’t know a thing about this movie going into it so really I had no pre-conceived notions. Overall, I enjoyed the movie but I found myself rather disconnected from it due to the subtitles. I had to keep myself entirely engaged or I would lose the plot and would not be able to connect with the story line. And then I realized something, this sense of disconnectedness was a major part of the story. I am not sure if the directors intended this but for me that made this movie that much more enjoyable.

For those who have not seen it, I will give you a quick summary. The movie starts off with a man, Hassan, selling a gun to a friend to hunt buck. The man buys the gun and allows his kids to take possession of it in order to hunt. The kids are very young and because of this small act, a tourist (an American) ends up being shot. The movie follows the paths of the three families that are involved in this story and how although they are so disconnected they are actually very connected.

This however leads me to a big question, should small children be able to use guns. I for one am a huge believer in the right to bear arms and I believe all families should be able to protect themselves. But, I think this movie shows that children cannot be trusted with guns. They do not quite understand the severity of their actions just yet and they do not understand the value of a human life. This movie showed me how disconnected these children felt from their actions even though their actions deeply affected more than just their own lives.

One of the children in Babel

Many people argue that with the right discipline and training a child can use a gun supervised for purposes such as hunting. I don’t believe this should be allowed. A child does not understand what it means to take a life, even an animal life. Until they can feel those types of connections and understand what their actions truly mean I do not think they should have that type of power.

I think the disconnectedness the viewer feels when watching this movie is similar to the disconnectedness the children felt when they shot the van than wounded the tourist. After watching this I can say with certainty that I do not believe children should have access to guns in any way. Children need to learn compassion and the value of a life before they have the ability to take a life.

Compassion

So bloggers, even if you have not seen the movie, do you feel children should have the ability to use a gun?

 

What do YOU think?

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Babel: Disconnectedness and Kids with Guns

  1. As a strong advocate of protecting the 2nd amendment and all it stands for, I believe any person, child or adult should have the right to use a gun if they so choose, WITH proper training, safety courses, and if a minor, adult supervision. With some incidents involving weapons in this movie, it wasn’t that they didn’t know how to shoot. They didn’t know proper handling of a great tool like a rifle. It should never be misused or treated or events like in Babel are very much possible. So long ramble said short yes I believe than can and should but only if responsible enough to handle it.

  2. Having kids myself, I know that even though they are smart, mature and responsible, I wouldn’t trust them with something that could hurt or kill another human or living creature. Sorry. They can just barely use the toaster oven to heat a frozen pizza without the cheese catching on fire and having them panicking and running down the hall screaming and giggling. Maybe if we lived on a farm and hunted and they were around guns, maybe, but not quite sure. I think it all depends on the kids, but not ours.

    • I have to agree with you. I was that kid that had the whole toaster oven issue. I feel like even with proper training I wouldnt fully understand the capabilities of a gun and I would not have been suited to have one or use one.

  3. There is a reason for the minimum age for driving. It is not just to reach the pedals. Cars can kill. The same is true for guns. I don’t care how much supervision a kid has or how much you instruct them to be careful, kids only seem to learn by pushing limits. Putting them in a life and death situation is just foolishness and irresponsible parentlng.

    • I 100 % agree. Kids are always looking to see how far they can go and guns are not toys. I am not sure kids would quite understand that no matter how much “instruction” they received.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s